Adam S. Montefiore



October 7th 2023
Or ran

At 6.30 am on the early morning of the Simchat Torah festival, Hamas terrorists invaded Israel in the north western Negev. It was the Sabbath, a time of tranquility and peacefulness. Most families were still in their beds. Hamas went from house to house, from community to community, murdering families in their beds and safe rooms in cold blood. At the same time there was a music festival in the name of peace, where young adults were dancing without a care in the world. Revelers were still partying when Hamas gunmen brutally mowed them down in their hundreds.

1,300 Israelis were slaughtered in the Simchat Torah Massacre. These were mostly civilians. Houses were set on fire and people were burned alive. Whole families were killed, including the elderly, women and children. Even babies were slaughtered in the most gruesome ways possible. Some were beheaded. Family dogs were sadistically shot. The people who perpetuated these horrors were Palestinian. They were in the guise of Hamas, the militant terrorist organization, but the methods were that of ISIS. More Jews lost their lives on October 7th than on any day since the Holocaust. To put it in context, this was the equivalent of America losing 35,000 people in one day. 

In addition Hamas took 150 hostages. They kidnapped mothers and babies, and grandmothers in poor health in their eighties and carted them off to Gaza. The civilized world showed its revulsion and President Biden of the United States gave a wonderful speech supporting Israel. It showed an empathy our own leaders have not managed to replicate. It will go down as one of the great speeches in modern times. Israel having been attacked, declared war on Hamas.

There is no one in Israel who does not know someone killed, kidnapped or missing. There is no industry or organization not affected. Wine was not targeted, but remains disrupted by the Simchat Torah Massacre and its aftermath. Winery workers have been called up the army. (The IDF is a people’s army.) Wineries have had to close.  Visitors’ Centers are not operating and there are no tourists anyway. The white grape harvest was finished, but the war has interrupted the completion of the red wine harvest. Many agricultural workers have been called up, but by hook or by crook, the wineries will get the harvest in. Nature does not wait for war.

Those that work in winery offices frequently have to run to bomb shelters. Whilst writing this article, the air raid sirens went off and  I had to run to the safe room where I waited until the all clear with my terrified, shaking dog, Lulu, for whom each boom is a trauma. Hamas has fired roughly 5,000 rockets on Israeli civilians. Schools have been closed; so many winery workers have to work from home whilst looking after restless children. The main region under attack is the Western Negev Desert and the southern Coastal Plain. This is the same Negev Desert wowing the world with how Israelis are making the desert bloom with vineyards. They have had to cope with frequent barrages of rockets fired indiscriminately into civilian areas. Even Tel Aviv and Jerusalem are targeted. Furthermore, the Upper Galilee and Golan Heights is Israel’s main wine growing area in the north of the country. Their vineyards are overlooked by the terrorist organization Hezbollah in Lebanon. They are allies of Hamas and proxies of Iran. There are daily skirmishes with rockets fired, but in the meantime a full-throated conflict is on a slow burner, but a spark could set it off at any time. However as a precaution, people have been evacuated from the nearby villages and communities to the border. In many cases vineyard workers can’t get to their vineyards. 

Far more shocking has been the loss of loved ones. Or Ran z”l was an example of Israel’s finest. He was felled in the prime of his life; one of the victims of the slaughter. He is the brother of Mika Ran Mandel, owner winemaker of Mika Winery, one of our most promising wineries. Heartfelt condolences to her and her family. May his memory be a blessing.

Oded and Yocheved Lifshitz

Others are missing. Over a week after the catastrophe, nothing has been heard about them. Daniel Lifshitz is the ex-goalkeeper of Maccabi Tel Aviv. He is a wine importer and one of the leading experts of Burgundy in the country. His company is called Bourgogne Crown. His grandparents Oded and Yocheved Lifshitz, respectively 83 and 85 years old, are amongst the missing. They were kidnapped on that terrible day. No-one knows where they are and there is no contact whatsoever. There is shock and outrage that civilians, children and the elderly should be held. Inhuman behavior. The house of Israel is praying for the healthy return of Daniel Lifshitz’s grandparents.

Omer Wenkart

The son of wine importer Shai Wenkart was another who went to that Peace Music Festival. Many young people were murdered in cold blood. Omer Wenkart was presumed to have survived but was one of the innocents carted away as a hostage. A week later the family have received no contact whatsoever; no indication of life. The families of the missing are going out of their minds. We want Omer back home with his family.

Castel rocket

The war also touches wineries in different ways. A Hamas rocket landed in one of the vineyards owned by Domaine du Castel, one of Israel’s leading wineries. Ironically it was the same vineyard burnt in a wild fire a couple of years ago. Castel is situated in the Judean Hills that rise towards Jerusalem. Ramat Negev Winery, one of the pioneers of the Negev Desert, received a surprise. A container of new bottles was hit by a rocket by Hamas. The bottles were largely destroyed but thankfully no-one was injured. However, it is an example of collateral damage.

Ramat Negev winery container

The country is at war. The roads are clear and the supermarket shelves are empty. People are hurting. The shock and horror is felt by everyone and is only repeatedly emphasized as more and more stories come to light. The positive thing is the spirit of Israelis, the togetherness and the determination. For the last ten months Israel has been split due to the actions of our most right wing government ever. The government had its agenda, and those opposing made their feelings known with enormous ongoing demonstrations that without precedent lasted over 40 weeks, which took place mainly at Kaplan Street in Tel Aviv, but also in 150 places around the country. The day of reckoning will come for the prime minister, ministers and government as well as the security, that presided over the biggest debacle in Israel’s industry. In the meantime Israel is united and focused. The disaster has brought Israelis together.

The world has been very supportive. I have been flooded with concerned messages conveying love and support from all over the wine world. At the same time the Palestinian demonstrations have started in capitals around the world. These are mainly made up of fanatical Muslims who rejoiced at the barbarism….as they did in New York, London, Paris and Madrid when those capitals were attacked by primitive, fundamentalist terrorists. My view is that those who stayed silent when Israel was attacked should not now comment wisely when Israel defends itself.

Israel has asked for civilians in Gaza to move out of fire. Hamas is telling them to stay put. That explains all you need to know. Israel is not targeting civilians. Our soldiers are not going in to Gaza to kidnap, kill, burn people alive, rape grannies, mothers, children and cut off baby’s heads.

This is not just an Israeli problem. The world has faced ISIS, Al Qaeda terror in its capital cities, but only when Israel is involved, does everyone become ultra sensitive. However, remember what starts with Israel & the Jews does not end with us. People need to understand the enemy is Iran; Hamas and Hezbollah are different heads of the same snake. The fundamentalist does not just hate Israel, but also western civilization. After they come for us, they will come for you as they have done in the past. 7/10 will be become known to Israelis and Jews like 9/11 is known to Americans. 

If you are an independent thinker, then you may wonder how the massacre has helped the Palestinian cause? If we can free Gaza of Hamas, then maybe we are doing the captive Gaza residents a big favor. Hamas is ISIS. They are not freedom fighters, but the darkest terrorists.

In the meantime, we remind you all Hamas are Palestinians, but not all Palestinians are Hamas. We bleed at the loss of life of innocent Palestinians. They also have women and children who are suffering unbearably, and we regret what is happening to them. However, Hamas attached Israel and inflicted the most savage, inhuman, animal carnage that we have known in our lifetimes. Can you imagine the United States or the United Kingdom not responding to an attack of such magnitude? We have no alternative. Please speak out. We are fighting for our lives.





Start-up distillery in the heart of Jerusalem


One of Israel’s most experienced winemakers


WINEing with Weizman
More wine talk articles from:

More articles

Yatir Forest 2005

Yatir Forest 2005

Yatir Forest is the de-luxe, prestige wine of Yatir Winery, which is situated at Tel Arad in the north east Negev desert

Read More +