Adam S. Montefiore
Search
MENU
Search

ARTICLES

THE ISRAEL PRIZE FOR WINE GOES TO…..

After 75 years of Israeli wine, some national recognition is long overdue

The revolution of Israeli wine over the last forty years has been one of Israel’s finest success stories. There have been steady developments each decade and as a result, Israeli wine has earned deep respect worldwide. It is frustrating that this has not yet been recognized here, because lately honors and awards are given for political kinship, rather than the old-fashioned concept of giving credit where it is due. It is high time the Israeli wine industry was recognized by the country itself. After all wine may not be our largest export, but it is Israel’s finest ambassador. As we celebrate Israel’s 75th anniversary, I have named the people that made a difference and epitomized their era in this amazing story.

Ben Guryon Carmel MizrahiThe first 35 years were the years of Carmel, the historic winery of Israel. The person that best represents this period is Elyakum Ostashinski who was CEO of SCV des Grandes Caves and Carmel Mizrahi for nearly thirty years from the early fifties. Previously he had been Mayor of Rishon Le Zion. This was a period in which Carmel Mizrahi was a monopoly. These were not great days of Carmel in terms of quality, but were in terms of dominance. Israeli wine did not have a great image, but times were different. Nevertheless, Carmel kept Israeli wine afloat through all the ups and downs of building the State. Ostashinski provided the stability and his high profile and longevity merited respect. Carmel’s greatest ever award would come far later, when the Carmel Kayoumi Shiraz won the International Trophy at the Decanter World Wine Awards in 2010.

James RothschildJames Rothschild was the son of Baron Edmond de Rothschild, who provided the finance and French expertise to found a wine industry. James left France and went to live in England. In 1957 he generously arranged to donate the Rishon le Zion and Zichron Ya’acov Wine Cellars to Carmel SCV. This was a move which secured the future of Israeli wine and gave it independence. Thus, the involvement and interest of the Rothschild family in the Israel wine industry extended from 1882 until 1957. This was the same Rothschild that donated the money to build Israel’s parliament building – The Knesset. David Ben Gurion, arguably the most famous person ever to work at Rishon Le Zion Cellars, wrote: “Truly a great father was followed by a son no less great.”

Avraham Meir Shor was one half of the AM Shor Bros, the winery founded in 1848 in the Muslim Quarter of the Old City of Jerusalem. In 1955 he and his brother split and he continued to make wine at the winery, which was renamed Zion Winery. It remains the oldest existing winery until today. For 175 years, the owner, manager and even the winemaker of the Shor – Zion Winery has always been a member of the Shor family. The other brother, Moshe Shalom Shor, went into the spirits business, but his children returned to wine in the Arza, Hacormim and Shimshon Wineries. Today there are no less than six wineries or brands owned by different branches of the Shor family: 1848, Arza, Hacormim, Hayotzer, Shorr (sic) Estate and Zion. A reminder for those that think Israeli wine began with Carmel or the Golan Heights Winery!

After the founding of the state, Menachem Teperberg founded a winery called Efrat in Western Jerusalem. This winery had roots in the Old City where his descendants had founded a winery in 1870. Unfortunately that winery went bankrupt. The winery Menachem founded was small and devoted to liquid religion, however his son Moti was to transform it. He changed its name to Teperberg Winery, moved to new premises and it is now Israel’s largest family winery and the third largest winery in Israel. Furthermore, Moti Teperberg has been at the helm as CEO for nearly forty years! He was responsible for the impressive turnaround.

In 1976, the first vineyards were planted on the Golan Heights and the Golan Heights Winery was founded in 1983. They wanted expertise from abroad and were put in touch with Peter Stern from California. He was to be the winemaking consultant for the next twenty years. Peter Stern, along with a series of his protégé Californian trained winemakers, re-invented Israeli viticulture and brought New World winemaking techniques to Israel, using the cooler climate, high elevation vineyards of the Golan.  Stern brought about a massive change in Israeli winemaking. The beginning of the quality revolution was due to him. It was Stern who set the standards that was to produce Israel’s first world class wines. Starting in 1987, the Yarden  Cabernet Sauvignons 1984 and 1985 began to win major international awards in London and Bordeaux, and Yarden has never stopped since.

Uri Shaked was the founder and CEO of Magash Shaked, leaders in distribution, importing and retailing. Shaked were the distributors who contributed greatly to the success of the Golan Heights Winery. They initiated a revolution in wine retailing with the founding of the Derech Ha’Yayin chain of wine stores. With street smarts and a great instinct, Uri Shaked has initiated and innovated, and his company has a finger in every pie.

Yarden

Eli Ben Zaken, was a self-taught winemaker, who learnt winemaking from a book by Emile Peynaud. He was founder-owner-winemaker of Domaine du Castel. By a stroke of good fortune his first wine, the Castel Grand Vin 1992, got noticed by Serena Sutcliffe MW, head of the Sotheby’s Wine Department. She wrote that it was the best wine Israeli wine she had ever tasted. Eli Ben-Zaken taught us about style, aesthetics, perfectionism and quality. Twice he built the most beautiful winery in Israel, first at Ramat Razi’el and then Yad Shmona. Castel was the pioneer of the Judean Hills Wine Region and led a new movement to blends instead of varietals. Castel showed that smaller Israeli wineries could also make world class wines. Castel gained third party recognition at the very highest level. In the 2000s, Castel was the first Israeli winery to receive Four Stars in Hugh Johnson’s Pocket Wine Book. In the 2010s Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate scored the Castel Grand Vin and C Blanc du Castel as Israel’s finest red and white wines; and in 2020s, James Suckling.com has awarded Castel the highest scores for an Israeli winery.

Since 1992, Victor Schoenfeld has been the legendary winemaker of the Golan Heights Winery. He introduced cutting edge viticulture to Israel.  Suffering from the leafroll virus, the Israel wine industry was slow to come up with solutions. The Golan Heights Winery, therefore decided to invest in their own Propagation Block and Nursery, which they did in cooperation with the French company, Entav. Following this, they undertook what they called Project 2020 to replace vineyards with virus with clean plant material. The winery then decided to become sustainable according to the protocol of ‘Lodi Rules’ from California. All these initiatives were led and implemented by Schoenfeld, who at the same time through his research, made the Golan Heights the most observed and studied agricultural land in Israel. The technology they use and data base of information they have, would impress many of the most advanced wineries the world over. The Golan Heights Winery shows incredible consistency across the board and everything is impressively done with a long-term interest in mind. During the Schoenfeld era the Golan Heights Winery won two awards that may be the best ever received by Israeli wineries: “Best Producer Worldwide” at Vinitaly and “The Star Award for Best New World Winery” presented by the Wine Enthusiast.

The late Daniel Rogov was the person who gave a voice to Israeli wine. He was the wine and food writer initially for the Jerusalem Post and later for Haaretz. Until he passed away in 2011, he faithfully recorded and wrote about Israeli wine with color and a flourish. His work was categorized in his Rogov’s Guide To Israeli Wines published annually. Now the era of the really dominant wine critic has passed and it is true to say he has not been replaced. A developing wine industry needs a media chronicler and Rogov was that man. 

Tali Sandovsky

In the early years, Israeli wine was virtually men only. Today, I am pleased to say women play an enormous role in the success of Israeli wine. The pioneers were Tali Sandovski and the late Carmi Lebenstein. Sandovski the senior winemaker at the Golan Heights Winery, is their longest serving winemaker and she was the first Israeli winemaker to gain a winemaking degree abroad. Lebenstein was the first woman in a senior position at a large winery becoming sales and marketing manager at Carmel Mizrahi at a time and in a place where women were scarcely seen.

Avi Ben Ami and Haim Gan through Studio Ben Ami and Ish Anavim (Grape Man), have both contributed greatly to Israeli wine in organizing competitions and exhibitions. Ben Ami a famous sommelier, founded a company that organizes the main trade exhibition, Sommelier, and the Best Value and Eshkol Hazahav (The Golden Cluster) competitions. Ish Anavim organizes exhibitions, runs wine courses and Israel’s main international competition, Terravino. Both Avi Ben Ami and Haim Gan have greatly enriched the Israeli wine scene with their activities. 

Dr. Shibi Drori, researcher at Ariel University and winemaker of Gvaot Winery, began a project to collect, catalogue and research all the local grape varieties his team could find throughout the country. With professionalism and dedication Drori and his team have done some outstanding work. They found over 120 varieties and of these, twenty varieties showed potential for wine. The research continues and Drori set up an experimental pilot winery at Ariel University. Following Cremisan Monastery’s lead, some wineries started to make wines from these varieties. Recanati’s Marawi caused worldwide interest. Now, one should not confuse the immense interest in these Holy Land varieties with quality. Cabernet Sauvignon and Chardonnay are not trembling yet, but the research is important and who knows where it will lead?

As a result of Eran Pick becoming Israel’s first Master of Wine, the interest in Israel wine was higher and reached further than ever before. Like the famous Heineken advertisement, Pick enabled Israeli wine to be seen with new eyes and reach places and people not accessible before. Part of this was also through the activities of the Judean Hills Quartet founded to market the region overseas. Quite apart from his effect on Brand Israel, Pick is CEO and winemaker of Tzora Vineyards. His work at this winery for me represents the current identity revolution, the adoption of precision viticulture, again, making blends instead of varietals and it also perfectly illustrates the comparatively new, outstanding quality of Israeli white wines. Above all is the idea of making a wine with a sense of place. Tzora’s wines have received Israel’s highest scores ever achieved in the Wine Spectator and Decanter Magazines.

Gal Zohar is a sommelier-wine consultant-wine educator, who is a Master of Wine candidate. He founded the W Wine & Spirit School representing WSET, the world’s most famous wine school, in Israel. This school has revolutionized wine education in Israel, educating a whole generation of Israelis, including wine professionals and wine lovers, to understand wine in an internationally accepted way. There are many great educators, none more so than Nir Shaham with his Soreq Winemaking School, whose modesty and quiet professionalism has had an effect on Israeli wine over decades that can’t be measured. However, no doubt the W School has been the most influential new development in Israeli wine in the last decade.

These are some of the names that represent 75 years of Israeli wine. Let’s suppose that in a moment of rational thinking, that the Israeli government will decide to pay homage to Israeli wine by nominating someone for “The Israeli Prize.” That person must be truly representative of the industry and also have played a significant part in the quality revolution. In my fantasy world, I am assuming the person would not be selected because they were friends of a minister, members of a political party or part of a fringe political movement or sector. In my naive world, wine would be the name of the game and the sole criteria in the selection. As for the suitable candidates, I can give my choice of three people who are up for the task and more than measure up. These would be Victor Schoenfeld, Eli Ben-Zaken and Eran Pick MW. These are people whose overall influence and contribution outweighs the parochial interests of the wineries they represent. The idea of awarding the Israeli Prize for Wine is long overdue. We have international third-party recognition at the very highest level. How about some recognition on a ‘national’ level! How much longer do we have to wait?

The writer is a wine industry insider turned wine writer, who has advanced Israeli wines for 35 years. He is referred to as the English voice of Israeli wine and is the Wine Writer for the Jerusalem Post. www.adammontefiore.com

THEJERUSALEM POST

WINE TALK

A HEART, A ROSE & A GLASS OF WINE

A HEART, A ROSE & A GLASS OF WINE

An expression of the Israeli spirit and the wine of defiance
In pursuit of a mission and a dream

IN PURSUIT OF A MISSION AND A DREAM

The mission of continuing to make cheese, and the dream of a winery
SEEING RED, DRINKING WHITE

SEEING RED, DRINKING WHITE

Reds still dominant, but whites are coming back
More wine talk articles from:

More articles

EXPENSIVE OR NOT?

EXPENSIVE OR NOT?

Mention the price of Israeli wines and there will surely be an argument between consumers who are tired that consumer goods always seem so expensive

Read More +
FELDSTEIN UNFILTERED

FELDSTEIN UNFILTERED

Avi Feldstein, poet, philosopher, barman, grew up in Tel Aviv, from Romanian roots and read Literature and Philosophy at Tel Aviv University. He started as

Read More +
THE KOSHER FLYING WINEMAKER

THE KOSHER FLYING WINEMAKER

Menahem Israelievitch is the flying winemaker of the kosher world. A Michel Rolland (the world’s most famous consultant winemaker) with a kippa if you like.

Read More +